Hegel and Lacan Meet The Rule of the Clan

Prof. Jeanne L. Schroeder of Cardozo Law School has written a fine, thoughtful, extended (and complimentary) review of The Rule of the Clan in which she reads my book through the framework of Hegelian philosophy and the psychoanalytic theory of French post-structuralist Jacques Lacan. She concludes: “In his defense of the classical liberal ideal of individual rights and equality, Weiner implicitly rejects one of liberalism’s founding propositions: a vision of the free individual in the state of nature. Weiner’s thesis is more consistent with the speculative tradition of Continental theory than with American liberalism.”

The link provided is to an abstract of Prof. Schroeder’s review on the Social Science Research Network (SSRN), where you can download her full, twenty-seven-page text. I understand that Prof. Schoeder will be sending her essay to law reviews in the upcoming submission cycle. I’m exceptionally gratified by the review, and very moved that my book inspired such deep intellectual engagement by a colleague.

In the meantime, this must be a good week for Francophilia, because “The Call of the Clan,” my recent essay for Foreign Policy, has just been published in French translation for Salte.fr as “De l’union européenne à l’Afghanistan … L’appel du clan,” in a translation by Peggy Sastre. Merci beaucoup, amis et compatriotes!

 

 

Distraction from the Storm

As hurricane Sandy bore down on the eastern seaboard, my wife and I thought that the best distraction from the howling wind and crack of breaking branches would be to curl up and watch movies. It didn’t take long for us to settle on Alfred Hitchcock.

And so after we made up our inflatable bed in the living room—the safest place, we figured, if one of the tall trees in the backyard crashed through the roof—and brought up our emergency kit from the basement—stove, check; fuel, check; tent, check; food and water, check—we unfurled the projector screen we normally use to display academic PowerPoint slides, made a bowl of buttered popcorn, and poured ourselves a beer.

All things considered, it seemed like the sort of thing that one would want to have been doing in the final moments before disaster.

Here’s a picture of our outpost in the storm:

The film on the screen is “North by Northwest”—there’s Carry Grant furtively walking through Penn Station.

Now that we’ve come through the storm safe and sound (a miracle), in this post I’d like to pull on a small thread in the film we saw last night, “Rear Window.” It’s a legal thread, and one that also happens to be entwined with an environmental theme.

There’s not much we can do for our friends in New York and New Jersey, who faired much worse than we did, but if they are able to read it, perhaps this distraction will be welcome.